Public sector bids aren’t won by the best salesperson. They’re marked by evaluators against a scoring scheme the buyer published in advance - and they have to stick to it. If you know how the marks are given, you can write to win them.
Pass/fail first
Before anyone reads your answers, the buyer checks whether you can take part at all. Expect questions about:
- Exclusion grounds - things like certain criminal convictions, unpaid tax or serious past failures
- Conditions of participation - minimum insurance cover, financial standing, accreditations or experience
These are usually pass or fail. Miss one and the rest of your bid won’t be marked, so check them the day you download the documents.
Quality and price
Most tenders split the marks between quality and price - say 60% quality and 40% price, or 70/30 for skilled services. The split is in the tender documents. The Procurement Act requires contracts to go to the most advantageous tender, judged against the published criteria - not simply the cheapest.
How price is usually marked
A common method gives the lowest price full marks and the others a share in proportion. For example, if price is worth 40 marks and the lowest price is £80,000:
| Your price | Marks |
|---|---|
| £80,000 | 40 |
| £100,000 | 32 (80,000 ÷ 100,000 × 40) |
| £120,000 | 26.7 |
So a price 25% above the lowest still keeps most of the price marks - often less than you’d lose by giving a weak quality answer. Some buyers use other methods (for example, comparing prices to a budget or an average), and the documents should say which.
How quality is usually marked
Each quality question has a weighting and a scale - often 0 to 5 (or 0 to 10) with a description for each score. A typical 0-5 scale looks like this:
| Score | What the evaluator is looking for |
|---|---|
| 5 - Excellent | Fully meets the requirement, with detailed, relevant evidence and real added value |
| 4 - Good | Meets the requirement with good evidence and few weaknesses |
| 3 - Satisfactory | Meets the requirement, but with limited detail or evidence |
| 2 - Weak | Only partly meets it; key points missing or unsupported |
| 1 - Poor | Significant gaps or concerns |
| 0 - No answer | Not answered, or doesn’t address the question |
The gap between a 3 and a 5 is usually evidence and specifics. On a question worth 20% of the quality marks, that’s a big swing.
Social value
Many tenders include questions on social value: what extra benefit your contract will bring - local jobs and apprenticeships, spending with local suppliers, cutting carbon, volunteering in the community.
- Central government departments and many of their agencies must give social value at least 10% of the total marks.
- Councils and other public bodies have to consider social value when buying larger services contracts, and most now include a question on it.
Make your commitments specific and measurable (for example “two apprenticeships in the first year, recruited locally”), and only promise what you’ll deliver - your commitments are written into the contract and checked.
How to pick up marks on every answer
- Answer the question that’s asked. Use the buyer’s words as headings, in the same order, and cover every part.
- Read the scoring descriptions and write to the top one. If “excellent” mentions evidence, give evidence.
- Prove it. Numbers, named examples, results from similar contracts, short case studies. “We always respond quickly” scores less than “we attended 96% of call-outs within 2 hours across 1,200 jobs last year”.
- Make it about this contract. Name the buyer, the sites, the people you’ll use, the risks you’ve spotted and how you’ll handle them.
- Respect the limits. Stick to word counts, page limits and the attachments asked for - evaluators can’t mark anything else.
- Check it’s complete. A missed sub-question is a missed mark. Have someone else read it against the scoring scheme before you send it.
After the result
On larger contracts under the Procurement Act, every bidder gets an assessment summary showing how their bid was marked against the winner’s. It’s the best free training you’ll get: it tells you exactly where you lost marks.
On Public Contracts Hub, every open tender page has a bid intelligence book: how that buyer usually marks bids, who has won similar contracts, how often small businesses win, and what the notice asks you to prove.
Put it into practice
See what's open now in your trade and area - tenders, early notices, contracts due for re-tender and subcontracting openings, updated three times a day.